For twenty euros
Adriano AntonuccioNov 20264 min read

Photo: T (tanyabarrow) on Unsplash
TL;DR
- Italy’s Arbitro Assicurativo has taken cases since 15 January 2026: a written complaint first, then EUR 20 and an online form. It received 1,499 in four months, 71% of them filed without professional help.
- Insurers reject 62% of the 107,460 complaints they receive in a year. In a first count of 56 decisions the customer won 14, and three more ended before a ruling, as happens when the claim is met after filing.
- Every case before the panel is an answer the customer did not accept. Whether a no was understood can be asked on the day it is sent.
A storm took a row of tiles off Marta’s roof. Her insurer declined the claim in two lines: the event is not covered by the policy conditions. She complained in writing and, three weeks later, received the same two lines again. Marta is invented; her case is put together from the kinds of dispute in the Arbitro Assicurativo’s first published decisions. Until this year, the next step was a court. Now it costs her EUR 20.
The Arbitro Assicurativo sits at IVASS, the insurance supervisor, which appoints its panel. It has taken cases since 15 January 2026, and the route is short. The customer complains in writing. The insurer has 45 days to answer. If the answer does not satisfy, the customer has 12 months from the complaint to file a case, a ricorso, online. The fee is EUR 20, and the insurer pays it back if the customer wins. A claim on a non-life policy can go up to EUR 25,000. The decision does not bind, and both sides can still go to court. But an insurer that does not comply within 30 days is named on the Arbitro’s site for five years and has to say so on its own site for six months. On 20 November that list held five names.
People use it. By 12 May, four months in, the Arbitro had received 1,499 ricorsi. Consumers filed 91% of them, and 71% came without a lawyer or any other professional.
What they send in matters more than how many they are. The complaint and the insurer’s reply are required attachments. The first thing the panel reads is the insurer’s own letter.
There are many such letters. Insurers operating in Italy received 107,460 complaints in 2025. They upheld 29.8%, settled about 8% and rejected 62%: more than 66,000 times in a year, an insurer wrote no. They wrote it quickly, in 21 days on average against the 45 allowed. Speed was never the problem.
The decisions are published in groups, the latest on 13 November. A lawyer who read 56 of the first ones counted 14 upheld in full or in part, 23 rejected, 15 inadmissible, one mixed, and three that ended before a ruling, as happens when the claim is met after the ricorso is filed. An insurer can read that as winning two cases in three. I read it differently.
Take the three that ended early. If an insurer meets a claim only once a ricorso is filed, what changed since the complaint? Perhaps a new document. Perhaps only who was going to read the file.
Take the cases the insurers won. In decision 486 of 16 June the panel rejected the customer’s claim, and still noted that the insurer had disclosed the referral of the file to its antifraud unit only when the ricorso was filed. Such a referral, it held, must come with at least a minimal reasoning. In decision 661 of 10 July the insurer won again, and the panel called its conduct over the customer’s online access open to censure.
And take the 38 the customers lost. Each is a customer who read the insurer’s explanation, did not accept it, and paid EUR 20 to say so. The panel did not find for them, which is not the same as their being convinced.
That is what the numbers miss. Insurers measure complaint handling by days to answer and by outcome. Neither says whether the customer understood why. A no that was not understood is not a closed case. It is a case that has not yet found its second reader.
Whether it was understood can be asked. One question with every reply to a complaint: did this answer make clear why? And room to write. Read together across a year of rejections, those answers show which clause, which standard letter and which step, a referral to antifraud, a request for one more document, leaves customers unconvinced. They also show the cases where the customer is right, while putting it right still costs only a letter.
The Arbitro’s first year ends on 15 January 2027, and its annual report will count the ricorsi and how they ended. Insurers can wait for it to learn which of their answers did not hold. Or they can ask the people who received them. Marta has already paid her EUR 20.
Sources
- IVASS, complaints received by insurers in 2025, press release of 11 May 2026 (PDF, in Italian)
- Arbitro Assicurativo, the conditions for a ricorso (in Italian)
- Arbitro Assicurativo, how a ricorso is filed and what it costs (in Italian)
- Arbitro Assicurativo, what it is and how far its decisions bind (in Italian)
- Arbitro Assicurativo, the panel and who appoints it (in Italian)
- Arbitro Assicurativo, the procedure and the 30 days to comply (in Italian)
- Arbitro Assicurativo, how failures to comply are published (in Italian)
- Arbitro Assicurativo, the list of companies and intermediaries that did not comply, read on 20 November 2026 (in Italian)
- Assicurazione.it, IVASS’s figures on the first four months of the Arbitro, 25 May 2026 (in Italian)
- Facile.it, the same figures with their source at IVASS, 10 June 2026 (in Italian)
- Arbitro Assicurativo, the decisions published in groups, the latest on 13 November 2026 (in Italian)
- Alessio Scatigna, a count of 56 early decisions of the Arbitro, 16 July 2026 (in Italian)
- Arbitro Assicurativo, decision 486 of 16 June 2026 (PDF, in Italian)
- Arbitro Assicurativo, decision 661 of 10 July 2026 (PDF, in Italian)
- Arbitro Assicurativo, the annual report and what it counts (in Italian)
Adriano AntonuccioNov 20264 min read
If this is the problem on your desk, we would be glad to show you how it works in practice.
Book a demo